Sunday, November 18, 2007

Cover story: how Metro will sell anything

Thanks to veteran freelancer David Hayes for his post on the Toronto freelance editors and writers listserv about the recent issue of Metro, the free commuter daily that is distributed in Toronto (and elsewhere). As Hayes says in his message to fellow freelancers: "Sell-outs don’t get much more blatant than this."

In a world where everything seems to be for sale, a publication's integrity is simply a commodity, apparently. An underwear company can buy the front page position on the assumption that it is a "wrap" and therefore not the "real" front page. However, by putting the publication's logo prominently on the ad, Metro is essentially saying that this publication is all about the advertiser's, rather than the reader's, needs.

Ads have crept onto the front pages of newspapers more and more, mostly in the form of "zippers" across the bottom and "ears" up around the logo, although at least some expectation is that the readers will know what is paid advertising and what is news.

Had Metro been a magazine, which it's not, it would have been flagrantly in contravention of the (albeit voluntary) ad:edit guidelines published by the Canadian Society of Magazine Editors and Magazines Canada. As it is, it should simply be ashamed of itself for not only not observing the line between ads and editorial, but for having erased it altogether.

6 Comments:

Blogger Rob said...

While this is the first time it's been an underwear ad, this is FAR from the first time Metro has sold its front page. Many days I've walked by the boxes and thought there was some big news regarding Rogers but no...it's just a full front-page ad. Needless to say, I don't pick it up.

We were taught in j-school how the front page sells the paper, thus it better be good. As you said, Metro is more about the advertisers than readers. Clearly they'd rather be in the bus shelter advertising market than you know, JOURNALISM.

12:26 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Back when my commute was long enough to allow time for reading, I made as big a show as I could of ripping these "wraps" off the Metro and tossing them in the recycling.

Although I wills say this: Metro "wraps" are better than the Toronto Star's new half-page wraps, which obscure editorial and ruin the page one layout. At least with the Metro, there's less of a feeling of interruption.

10:25 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am fine with it. The advertising wraps doesn't affect my decision to pick up this newspaper. As readers, I think it is important to remember that this publication is FREE for us.

10:46 am  
Blogger nicholasT said...

replying to jeromy lloyd;

maybe the right way to think is that all ad wraps on newspapers have a negative effect. But, of course, media marketers would have trouble thinking this way when they read comments such as jeromy's which they use to justify their actions

11:05 am  
Blogger Joyce Byrne said...

I'm curious what you think of the Canadian Tire ad on the front flap of the Maclean's Nov 19 issue, then?

12:39 pm  
Blogger D. B. Scott said...

Didn't see the Maclean's flap, but I imagine I'd say much the same.

2:32 pm  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home